Tag it:
Furl it!

Faculty hate being told what to do. When Gordon Wood, the history departments Pulitzer prize winning expert on early U.S. history, delivered Browns inaugural Constitution Day lecture a year ago, he couldnt resist a swipe at Congress for dictating that all institutions receiving federal funding host some activity to honor the U.S. Constitution.


This fall, in the second speech fulfilling that annual requirement, Assistant Professor of Political Science Corey Brett-schneider took a different approach. Not only did he defend the day; he asked his enthusiastic audience of students and faculty to consider what we owe the Constitution as citizens. The Constitution, he said, doesnt just exist because it always has, but it exists because of the parties that re-enforce it.

A lawyer and a political theorist, Brettschneider titled his speech Beyond Rights: The Constitutions Responses to Hate Speech. He cited two seemingly similar cases that the Supreme Court judged very differently. In one, the Ku Klux Klan burned a cross on a mans lawn after an altercation; the Court deemed the act to be a threatening illegal assault. But in another case, where the Klan burned a cross at a rally, the Court judged the act to be protected speecha hateful viewpoint but protected nonetheless. The illegal act, according to the Court, was the threat, not the speech.

The ideology of the Klan is an anti-Constitutional viewpoint, he reminded his audience, opposed in particular to the Fourteenth Amendments Equal Protection Clause. Groups like the Klan challenge the idea of equal protection and pluralism. But one of the strengths of the Constitution is that it protects even anti-Constitutional viewpoints.

The Constitution is finally about a kind of commitment to the idea of democracy, Brettschneider explained. With it come responsibilities, such as arguing back when confronted with hateful viewpoints. We need to protect and challenge these hateful viewpoints, Brett-schneider reminded his listeners or risk going further in the opposite direction.

Maybe Constitution Day isnt such a bad idea after all.

Be the first to comment on this article

Name and Class Year:

Code:* Code